Phase Three

In phase three you will begin your research and do two distinct things (KEEP them distinct): first, you will write a thesis paragraph, and second you will compile a list of premises in support of your thesis.

Thesis paragraph: Having settled on a thesis that meets the criteria (clear, substantive, particular, something you think may be true and for which you can give reasons, subject to reasonable challenge, and stated in a simple declarative sentence), you will now frame a paragraph that a) explains its terms and scope, as needed, and b) frames and contextualizes the issue as one needing an argument. There are several ways to do the latter, but the basic task is to show your reader why your thesis matters, what's at stake, and (if a reader might find your thesis too obviously true) that some reasonable people think otherwise.

Notice that it should not be possible for a reader of your paragraph to be mistaken for one instant about what the thesis is for which you are arguing. Nor should there be anything else in the thesis paragraph -- in particular, do not include in it any reasons in support of your thesis (save those for the body of the paper).

Premises: Next, list the premises you think will support your thesis. Include all sorts of considerations you can find or think of that support your thesis (examples, research findings, common wisdom -- relevant facts of all sorts). Write each as a single, declarative sentence. Do not (yet) include your grounds for thinking each is true, but notice which ones need the most support, as you may yet decide to make one of your premises into your thesis, as a way of scaling the project down.

This phase is due on Wednesday, October 5th at 5 pm, but it is a good idea to meet with Kyle or myself before then to make sure you're on track.